Why Stocks Can Drop After Good Earnings

Written by Jeremy Lieber

October 28, 2023

Every quarter, companies announce their earnings to the public. It’s a time of excitement and anticipation for investors and traders alike. Positive earnings can lead to a jump in share prices, but not always. Sometimes, stocks can drop after a report of good earnings, and this can be confusing and frustrating for investors. Understanding the reasons behind these drops is crucial for traders who want to succeed in the market. In this post, we’ll explore the factors that can cause a stock to drop after good earnings and what traders can do to uncover why.

Factors That Can Contribute to a Stock Dropping

Regarding the stock market, surprises can range from exciting to downright devastating. It can be incredibly frustrating to hear that a company you invested in beat analyst expectations only to see its stock price drop. Unfortunately, this is a common phenomenon in the world of trading. While several factors can influence the value of a stock, some of the most significant factors include changes in management, weak guidance, buy the rumor and sell the news strategy, lack of volume buyers, and share buybacks. Let’s take a closer look at each of these.

Changes in Management

Investors may be quick to sell off their shares if a company experiences a change in management, even if they just reported impressive earnings. When a new leader takes over, there is always a new level of uncertainty surrounding the company’s future direction and performance. This hesitancy can cause a dip in stock prices, as investors are unsure how the new leadership will navigate the company’s growth. If the leadership is untested or unproven, it only adds to the apprehension and can cause a more significant drop in share prices. While earnings reports are critical benchmarks for investors, management changes can majorly impact a company’s future success.

Weak Guidance

Weak guidance is a situation where a company forecasts future earnings that are lower than analysts’ expectations. Essentially, investors may start to doubt the company’s ability to perform well over the long term, which can cause the stock price to decrease. So, while earnings reports are essential, savvy investors must also pay attention to guidance.

“Buy the Rumor, Sell the News” Strategy

This is a common trading strategy where investors buy stocks based on rumors of positive news and then sell them once the news is officially announced. This can cause a temporary boost in share prices as investors rush in to capitalize on the good news. However, once the news is out, the value can drop as quickly as it rose.

Lack of Volume Buyers (Liquidity)

Liquidity refers to the availability of buyers and sellers in the market. If there aren’t enough buyers interested in purchasing the shares at the current price, there’s no upward pressure to keep the stock price at its current level. This means that as sellers begin to outnumber buyers, the price can start to dip, regardless of how well the company is doing financially.

Share Buybacks

Share buybacks are when a company buys back its shares from shareholders. While this can increase a stock’s earnings per share, it can also decrease the number of outstanding shares, causing the stock price to appear inflated. If investors view this as unsustainable, they may sell, causing a price drop.

Panic Selling and Its Impact

Panic selling is when investors sell their shares in a company because of fear, uncertainty, or doubt. This can cause a rapid drop in share prices, often during economic turmoil or when there’s negative news about a company. The impact of panic selling can be damaging, especially for those unprepared for it. It’s essential for traders to stay calm during market downturns and not let their emotions dictate their decisions. Sticking to a long-term investment strategy may help you weather the storm during periods of volatility.

How Traders Can Uncover the Reasons for Price Drops

As a trader, it’s essential to investigate why a stock has dropped. Traders can use various tools to uncover the reasons behind a price drop, including technical analysis, news and social media analysis, and fundamental analysis. Technical analysis involves looking at charts and identifying patterns and trends. News and social media analysis involves monitoring news outlets and social media platforms for any news or discussions about the company. Fundamental analysis involves looking at a company’s financial statements, industry trends, and other macroeconomic factors that could impact the stock’s price.

Stocks can drop after good earnings, and several factors can contribute to this. Understanding these factors is crucial for traders who want to succeed in the market. While panic selling can be damaging, it’s also an opportunity for traders to buy undervalued stocks and profit from the market’s recovery. To be successful in trading, it’s essential to stay calm, do your research, and always be prepared for the unexpected. By following these tips and strategies, traders can become more successful and confident in their investments. If you need any help with your trading journey, please get in touch with Uncommon Education Trading. Uncommon Education Trading is here to support traders and help them grow their careers through education and mentoring. So keep learning, stay informed, and happy trading! See you at the top of the market!

Related Articles

Mastering Day Trading: Understanding Risk/Reward Profiles

Mastering Day Trading: Understanding Risk/Reward Profiles

Day trading is a high-risk, high-reward profession that requires a high level of knowledge and skill to be successful. One of the most important aspects of day trading is managing risk, and a crucial tool for doing so is the risk/reward profile. This profile is a...

Scaling In/Out Strategies for Day Traders

Scaling In/Out Strategies for Day Traders

Day trading can be a lucrative career, but it's not without its risks. One of the biggest challenges many in the industry face is minimizing risk while capturing profitable market conditions. That's where scaling in/out strategies come into play. This strategy can...